The great and wondrous tales of Frugal Man – stop renting your modem.

renting your modem

Sharing is caring!

[This issue of Frugal Man about renting your cable modem may contain affiliate links at no cost to you]

It’s an affordable bird, it’s a reasonably priced plane, it’s FRUGAL MAN!

Hey kids and adults, Frugal Man here. It’s a pleasure to meet you. I’m sure my renown has reached your ears already but just in case it hasn’t, allow myself to introduce….myself.

I am Frugal Man, the economical super hero. I am spartan, prudent, thrifty and prudent. That’s double the prudence baby! My enemies may call me cheap but they’re just jealous of my perfectly chiseled features, perfect physique and ability to save money. Just look at me up there in that picture at the top. I am handsome and I have a dollar sign on my chest. The dollar signifies money if you weren’t aware. Frugal Man knows money and Frugal man is handsome.

Frugal Man’s powers are many but the most important is making the most out of every dollar. And yes, I do often talk about myself in third person. Such is the way of Frugal Man.

Those that call me cheap or a miser simply do not understand. The essence of frugality isn’t hoarding money, it’s making sure that your money goes towards things that bring you happiness and help you hit your future goals. That is what Frugal Man is here to tell you.

How do you know that you can trust me? First of all, have you seen the dollar sign on my chest and my excellent physique?

If that’s not enough to convince you then just look at the picture up top and notice something. I didn’t even splurge on color because I knew that it would bring low incremental value but cost quite a bit. If I can get 90% of the result for 20% of the cost, why would I spend the extra money? That’s not the Frugal Man way.

Plus without color, it looks more vintage and that’s hip these days.

No color was a good decision, that’s got the Frugal Man guarantee.

I am Frugal Man; I know these things. Frugal Man knows many things and I’m here to share them with you. In this issue of Frugal Man, we’re talking about cable modems.

Renting your modem

If you’re in your computer room right now then look over at your modem. It’s the big plastic thing with magic inside that allows you to access the internet and all its wonders.

Does your modem say Comcast on it or does it have the name of another internet provider? If it does then you might be getting ripped off!

Frugal Man will not stand for that!

We all have to access the internet. Even Frugal Man needs to get on to surf the worldwide web from time to time to do some research. The only difference is that I actually surf it like it’s a wave because I’m a super hero.

Comcast, like many evil corporations, actually doesn’t give you that modem for free just so you can use their service! You have to rent it from them(GASP!), sometimes unknowingly since they’re the ones that installed it and likely didn’t tell you there was an extra fee for it.

I know, it’s outrageous but it’s true. You would think that the high monthly fee would be enough but they want more! While more revenue for Comcast is good for their shareholders, it’s not good for the customer(that’s you) unless the rental fee is fair.

I know what you’re asking in your head. You’re saying, “Frugal Man, please use your super powers to tell me if it’s fair, please.”

I shall.

Well, let’s take a look at what Comcast charges. The rental fee is $10 per month. Using the power of mathematics, that adds up to $120 per year.

Is that fair?

It is not! In fact, I would call that a ridiculous charge considering the equipment provided by Comcast isn’t even top of the line.

You might say, it’s only $10 per month, what’s the big deal? That’s where Frugal Man comes in to hit you with a punch of financial knowledge.

The Frugal Man convinces you to stop renting your modem

It doesn’t make much sense to rent a modem if you can buy one. Here’s why!

Have you heard about the 4% rule? That simple rule is used by retirees to figure out how much they should withdraw once they retire to keep their cash from running out. If you’re paying your internet provider $10 per month to rent a modem, that means you need a constant flow of cash to support that habit if you wish to keep your internet forever.

Using the 4% rule, that comes to $3000 invested in the stock market today to keep the man from cutting of your internet and taking away your rental. In essence, the value of that $10 monthly payment for the rest of your life is $3000 right now.

That means it makes sense to buy a modem if it costs less than $3000!

Do they? Most definitely.

As an example, you can get a great modem like the one Frugal Man uses. Even, if you want a separate wi-fi router like this one then the combined cost of modem + router is still well below that.

I’m no tech wiz but I’d still suggest the stand alone modem and a separate wi-fi router as the router’s reach is often better. In most cases you can find a good modem + wi-fi combination for less than $200.

The Frugal choice is obviously the latter as $200 is much less than $3000. If Comcast wanted to be fair then their monthly rental charge should be south of $1(4% of $200 is $8 per year or $.666 per month)!

666 is the number of evil! That shows you just how much of a rip off the rental is for consumers!

As a fun little experiment, let’s assume you pay $10 per month starting at the age of 25 then by the time you’re 65, you’d have paid Comcast $4,800!

That’s a nice chunk of recurring revenue for that company! Now imagine, instead of doing that, you purchase a super fancy modem yourself for $240 giving you an ever better modem than Frugal Man has.

It’s OK, you deserve it although the one I have is plenty fine!

That equals first two years of rental fees gone in an upfront payment. It hits you in the wallet more today but improves your personal cash flow in the future starting at age 27.

When you’re 27, you can invest that $10 per month in a stock index fund earning 7% per year. Instead of paying Comcast $4,800 by the time you’re 65, you now have money working for you starting at age 27, have a modem and a cash hoard of $22,157 by the time you’re 65.

That’s a lot of money generated for you in the long run by buying versus renting! The best part is that the modem and router you can buy often perform better than what Comcast provides.

Now, there are some caveats here that Frugal Man must tell you.

Modems don’t last forever. Renting means you’d automatically get a replacement each time technology shifts or your modem breaks.

If you’re not renting then you’d have to buy one again in those situations leading to more out of pocket costs. However, if you’re investing that $10 per month then you’d still be well ahead even if you have to buy a new modem every couple of years. You likely won’t need that often since technology doesn’t shift that much every few years.

Most modems now support Docis 3.0 and that will likely be the standard for a while. Future man knows some technology! I’ve had my modem for a few years now and still hasn’t had any issues. I don’t expect to replace it for quite some time either.

Another concern for people who aren’t tech-savvy is that you have to install the purchased modem yourself. Luckily this is very easy. You can either follow the directions on a page like this from your IP or just call your internet provider to give them the numbers at the bottom of your modem. That’ll activate your own modem in no time.

One thing to be careful with is returning your modem. I suggest bringing it back to a physical location for your internet provider and getting a receipt. Make sure to check next month’s bill to confirm that the rental fee is off and call if it isn’t.

A future problem may be the fact that your IP can change their pricing metrics any time. It’s possible that they may start charging a service fee even if you have your own modem. AT&T’s DSL service for example has a $7 fee whether or not you have your own equipment.

Most cable companies like Comcast, Optimum and Spectrum charge a fee but not all of them are $10. Still, even at $5 per month, the math still easily works out in favor of purchasing a modem.

Frugal Man defeats evil(the conclusion)

Math never lies because I punched it once. In this case, it tells you that it’s clearly more frugal and economic to ditch the rental and buy your own modem.

Most product descriptions like the one here will tell you whether a specific internet provider supports that modem but you can also check on your specific provider’s website.  Since the end result is the same, you get internet, it doesn’t make sense to spend more than you need to on it.

Renting can sometimes make sense but not in the case of your modem. The amount of money you save can be invested and reap great rewards when you’re old and your bones hurt and all you want to do is sit on your butt and watch youtube videos of cats. You need a modem to do that and it’s better to have your own.

Now get out there and buy a modem and stop paying those evil internet companies more money than you need. So says Frugal Man and Frugal Man is almost always right.

If you’ll excuse me, I have to fly off and save somebody from paying too much for their mutual funds.

“Those expense ratios are through the roof friend, don’t do it!”


Disclosure : Comcast isn’t really that evil. Their evilness is used for comedic effect. I have them, they’re pretty good. I do not own any Comcast stock nor have plans to buy any either. Frugality is cool. Renting your modem is not.

#Frugal #Funny #Renting


15 thoughts on “The great and wondrous tales of Frugal Man – stop renting your modem.

  1. Haha love it! Frugal man is the best 🙂

    I’ve always used my own router, not because of the renting cost, but because of the low quality of most of the ISPs router. But I guess I’ve saved a lot of cash then.

  2. We are Comcast customers also. It’s like having a second mortgage without building equity. I remember back in the day when all they offered was basic cable which included 20 or 30 channels for about $15 bucks a month. Oh, how the world has changed. For the better, I think.

    1. Definitely better but the cost and bundling aspect of cable internet is a drag especially since most people only have one option.

  3. My husband couldn’t put up renting a modem even before his pre-FIRE days. I think it’s ingenious because it works for people who don’t care about money/not aware of money. Goes into Comcast’s pockets.

  4. You DO have to watch the bill, though–they get taken by surprise if you have your own and sometimes “forget” to take the rental charge off, or ask you for “the modem you’re renting” back when you close the account. That’s happened to us twice. But now we have 1GIG ATT Fiber and we’ve been pretty happy with that. No Direct TV, either.

  5. I remember when I switched from renting the modem to owning my modem. First, they raised my monthly bill, which made me look at it. I think they were charging something along the lines of $10 a month for the modem. The exact same modem from Amazon, used, was $8. So I paid more a month than what the modem was worth.

    I bought a better modem from Amazon. A supposed benefit of renting is they always keep you with the latest modem. Hah, no they don’t.

    1. Yea they totally give you crappy gear. They did update the one you rent recently but the performance still lags some of the $100 modems you can get online.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.