The Time in the Market expense report – November 2017

Happy Holidays, it’s almost time for Christmas and the roads outside look like an ice skating rink after a night of sleet and freezing rain; that means it’s the perfect time to look at my savings rate and expenses for last month!

I’m not looking forward to walking my dog in a few hours and will have to make sure to put on my ice cleats before going out. Still, I suppose I shouldn’t complain – it could look like this!

ice storm

One of the takeaways from my Q3 goal review was that I was behind on my savings rate.

It was already well into October when I wrote that so there wasn’t much I could do to impact that month. That means that if I want to hit my bronze goals in the savings rate area, I needed to buckle down and become a frugal Joe for November and December.

Who’s frugal Joe? It’s a guy that’s frugal and the goal for November and December was to emulate him and get that savings rate as close to 50% as possible.

October turned out pretty decent with a 39.8% savings rate which was above my Q3 total but still below my 40% target for the year. That means that November and December will really have to pick up the slack if I’m to hit my goals this year so let’s see how things turned out in November.

One thing to note is that I wanted to change up this month’s report a bit so I’m trying one of those newfangled Sankey diagrams that everyone is in love with these days when looking at my expenses and savings rate. 

Gross Income Savings Rate

gross income savings rate November 2017


On a gross income basis, I saved 39.4% of my income which is one of the best months I’ve had this year. Only February was better and that was because that’s the month I receive my bonus. I generally I bump up my 401k contributions to 50% whenever that happens to really drive the savings rate up and get a big head start on maxing out my 401k.

The addition of employer contributions brings this number up to 44.41%!

The 2017 bronze goal here is 30% so that’s a good deal above that. I was at 28.1% after Q3 so this number will certainly help drive me closer to that goal.

Savings Rate and Expenses

savings rate November 2017

My savings rate for the month clocks in at an impressive 54.58%. Again, that’s the second best month behind February.

That’s a big improvement over last month and will go a long way to help hit that savings rate goal of 40% for the year.

The savings rate jumps to 61.5% when I adjust for employer contributions.

That’s an awesome result and I’m pleased that I was able to get this number so high without trying all that hard. It all came down to cutting back on some common expenses like going out to eat.

The best part about these results is that I didn’t feel like I was limiting myself.

I still did most of the things I like to do but was more thoughtful about expenses that may impact my savings rate. I was also lucky in that I didn’t have some expenses that have marred the previous months like some high doctor bills and vet costs but it wasn’t all luck as I adjusted for some of the things I can control like restaurant expenses.

Let’s take a look at what drove the savings this month by utilizing the Sankey diagram to visualize the expenses and savings.

I used my actual income below since it better illustrates exactly where the money is going. In future iterations, I may remove the amounts.

Sankey Diagram

The Sankey is pretty great in that it shows exactly where my money is going and helps me visualize the actual impact of various costs.

One thing of note is that I’m still getting income from my writing side hustle which is cool to see. That’s despite being ultra lazy and not writing much since my last update which spoke of my struggles with sticking with it. It’s definitely something I plan to get back into in 2018 to try to generate some extra income.

Through the Sankey diagram, I can see that most(>50%) of my money is going to savings which is good to see and makes me feel good about this month.

In prior updates, I broke down the expense category on a % basis of overall expenses but that’s not a great way of looking at it because it can overstate certain costs. This diagram lets you see exactly how much certain things cost and how that relates to the net income.

As an example, rent made up 38.1% of my expenses this month which may make people thing I spend way too much on rent but $956 in a HCOL area isn’t too bad. The only reason I’m able to keep it that low is that I split the rent with my fiancee which is key in helping my savings rate.

The car is my second highest expense making up 18.1% of the overall expenses. That expense is due to my car loan which has about two years left. I’ve been tossing extra money at it here and there and may actually try to pay off the entire thing in 2018. I have about $7000 left and that will mean I only have to throw about 2k extra at it to get it out of the way and free up extra cash flow for 2019.

Groceries were next and made up 9.6% of the expenses. That’s probably one of the higher totals this year and coincided with the reduction in restaurant spending.

I’m a frequent visitor of Trader Joe’s and actually love grocery shopping and finding new things to try.

Lately, I’ve been a huge fan of their new almond butter based salad dressing so I’ve been eating a lot of salads for lunch. Greens + nuts + lots of cheese + salad dressing/olive oil = my idea of a good lunch.

The rest of the costs aren’t surprising.

Some key takeaways are that I pay too much for parking since I work in the city and my company doesn’t offer free parking. On the subject of benefits from work, my health insurance is low these last few months of the year because I got a premium credit late in the year so it’s impacting these months in a bigger way as that’s generally something that’s credited every paycheck.

My entertainment bill was entirely due to Netflix and my Apple Music subscription.

I generally avoided most black Friday sales but I did make a few purchases. I got my girlfriend her Christmas gift and I spent a bit of money on clothes this month getting two pairs of sweet Puma sneakers to replace my old ones. The sneakers were on sale from their standard $60 MSPR to $29.99.

Pet expenses were entirely food related although those are going to jump next month as we had to make a vet visit and put our beautiful doodle on some prescription food to see if we can help her with her allergies. Poor thing is itchy all the time!

The side hustle expenses are related to my blog costs.

Looking forward to the holidays, my family doesn’t do gifts expect for the things we get for the kids in the family. That’s great for my savings rate so December might be a solid month as well.

My fiancee and I don’t make a big deal of out Christmas and prefer small things anyway so the cost there isn’t huge any given year. The older we get, the less we seem to want as the things we want are all things money can’t buy.

That’s it for November’s update and I’m looking forward to see what December looks like and whether I can use these last two months to help me reach those 2017 goals. I’m a bit behind but November is certainly a good start towards that bronze goal.

Please let me know how you like the Sankey diagram and whether there’s any other information you’d like to see. If you’d like to make your own Sankey diagram, you can check it out here. It’s pretty simple to use and a great visualization tool. If you like the Sankey diagram, please check out others from some fellow bloggers like JumpStartFromScratch, Othala Fehu, GetRichSlowly, Biglaw Investor, Atypical Life, Military Dollar, The Frugal Gene and 99to1 Percent!

As always, thanks for stopping by and I wish happy holidays to all!


13 thoughts on “The Time in the Market expense report – November 2017

  1. Great job on the savings rate TITM. We really need to focus and work to cut our expenses because I know there’s a lot of leaks there. Any one by themselves isn’t much but add them all up and it’s a good amount each month.

    1. Thanks Troy – I’m certainly pleased with the November results! Thanks for the good wishes and a fruitful new year to you too!

  2. Great work at saving this month indeed! Which medal does it set you up for after great November? 🙂
    One of my goals for next year is to start tracking a budget – I haven’t managed to have one so far but hope to change that in the future…

    1. I think I’m still below Bronze right now but hopefully December will be a good one too although I just paid an old medical bill so who knows!

      I definitely suggest at least tracking your expenses – it’s totally helpful in seeing where the money actually goes.

  3. Hi Time. Happy holidays. I like the Sankey diagram. For whatever reason I have a hard time mentally processing charts. This one is easy to digest, so I like it. Would love to hear about the successes and challenges of your writing side hustle in 2018 as you focus on it more. Tom

    1. I’ll definitely have to get some more posts in about my side hustle and I agree that the Sankey really lays it out in an easy to understand visualization.

Leave a Reply